This collar is great for the water, especially when used with the biothane leash. I use both when kayaking with my dog, who wants to be in the water more than the kayak.
I bought the extra small all-terrain harness for my Miniature Pincher who gets out of everything. With minimal adjustments, the harness fits him perfectly and it's very sturdy. He hasn’t tried once to get out of it. That tells me he finds it comfortable.
These are the best harnesses my pups have had! I’m able to use both the front and back loops of the harness to connect my guy to his leash. Gives me so much control!